Wednesday, July 13, 2011

"Oh, East is East, and West is West, and never the twain shall meet." - Rudyard Kipling

Although I appreciate the significance of the sentiment, and how it condenses popular western thought, the source poem concerns British imperialism and the practical complications of the implementation of hegemony. But it is fitting, as we in the west are taught identity is as much about what we are not than about what we actually are. I really only have my own cultural experience to substantiate this argument, but I have some confidence that this is a universal human trait - to define identity by "foreigness" - by what we are not. For me, it is a big question - what defines a people. Is is what we are, or what we are not? I reflect upon my understanding of the world as a young boy for this, for when I was, say, five years old, I certainly recognized certain persons as being different enough to raise feelings of "foreign-ness". And I certainly believe that particular people in this world depend upon this sense of foreignness as a key component of their world view. There is a sense some people have - to be direct - that only white Americans are really American, that all others are somehow excluded from this American-ness. A ridiculous thought, of course, upon any sensible examination of American history - or just - an examination of reality, but it persists nonetheless. I recently read about a Japanese man, who having spent his life in Germany, and having certainly achieved acculturation or assimilation, not to mention success in business, was rejected on his application to join a fencing club in Munich. The reason given, of course, was that it would erode the German-ness of the club. Never mind the historical affinity of these two cultures, or that Germany is now some % Turkish. This man gets blamed for an erosion of German culture. This is not my concern, of course, but I had some hope that after their flawed experiment in facism the German people might take some latitude in their tolerance for foreign-ness. But no, they still want to exclude.

Social identity, while a common human trait, is also a common human myth. There are no real others that can't be assimilated, or tolerated. It's really just a myth that preys upon our common human social needs for acceptance. And this western belief that the East somehow represents its opposite is not factual in any way.

Alexander the Great established a fairly transient empire that extended from Greece to the Indus River Valley, and into the Fergana Valley in modern day Tajikistan, a stone's throw from the People's Republic of China. This Empire was known as the Seleucid Empire, and was ruled by his descendents and preferred generals. It didn't last that long but it did establish an important cultural bridge. For a time, Ancient Greek was the court language in portions of modern-day India.

The person who became known as the Buddha lived around 500 B.C. This is roughly when the flowering of ancient Greek philosophy occurred. There was a cultural bridge to India at this time, achieved by the armies of Alexander, and it is not unreasonable that the respective cultures exchanged ideas.

In fact it is not unreasonable at all. Particular Greek philosophers, like Pyrrho, Anaxarchus and Onesicritus, actually ventured to India, and studied there, in the birthplace of Buddhism.

It is truly difficult to find scholarship that confirms such a deep connection between the most important traditions of East and West: Greek and Buddhist. But it is clear that those connections are real. And upon examination of the respective values of these traditions it is not at all difficult to appreciate the connection. They are real and have given rise to the value systems of both cultures.

Thus, East and West have a shared cultural lineage. In the deep, dark past we really did talk to each other.

No comments:

Post a Comment